ARCHIVE

CBI a "caged parrot": Judge

AN ANGRY Supreme Court judge has berated India's Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) in his sta...

Staff Reporter

This article is 12 years old. Images might not display.

Justice RM Lodha called the agency a "caged parrot" and "its master's voice" after it was revealed that the CBI presented a draft report of its investigation into the scandal to government officials before submitting it to the Supreme Court last year.

On Monday, CBI director Ranjit Sinha provided the Supreme Court with a nine-page affidavit detailing who the draft was presented to and what changes were made.

The Indian Express reported that CBI Director Ranjit Sinha cited in his affidavit two "significant" changes made in the report after the Law Minister's intervention but neither of the changes made have "altered the central theme of the report, nor shifted the focus of inquiries or investigations in any manner”

The affidavit stated that "no names of suspects or accused were removed... no accused or suspects were let off in the process" and there was "no deletion of any evidence" against anyone.

But Judge Lodha disagrees, stating in court that the "heart of the report" had been altered, a damning statement for the CBI which proudly proclaims its motto to be "Industry, Impartiality and Integrity".

The Supreme Court judge's statement gave, for the first time, an authoritative voice to opposition complaints that for years India's Congress party-led government had been using the investigating agency to mask wrongdoing.

However, two former CBI directors told Reuters that the agency was subject to political influence, irrespective of which party happened to be in power at the time.

When the hearing began earlier in the week, the top court said it would seek to free the federal investigation body from political interference, according to Bloomberg.

The court hearing has severely disrupted parliament and prime Minister Manmohan Singh is now being called on to step down.

The scandal was exposed when, in March 2012, a leaked government audit suggested the state had squandered more than $US200 billion by allocating coal blocks instead of allowing competitive bidding.

The report, which the Times of India called “mind-boggling”, ruffled reformers within the Indian coal industry, led to the opening of public coal block auctioning and recently resulted in direct corruption accusations against the country’s chief of government.

The CBI report was an investigation into the matter.

TOPICS:

Expert-led Insights reports built on robust data, rigorous analysis and expert commentary covering mining Exploration, Future Fleets, Automation and Digitalisation, and ESG.

Expert-led Insights reports built on robust data, rigorous analysis and expert commentary covering mining Exploration, Future Fleets, Automation and Digitalisation, and ESG.

editions

ESG Index 2025: Benchmarking the Future of Sustainable Mining

The ESG Index provides an in-depth evaluation of the ESG performance of 60+ of the world’s largest mining companies. It assesses companies across 10 weighted indicators within 6 essential ESG pillars.

editions

Automation and Digitalisation Insights 2025

Discover how mining companies and investors are adopting, deploying and evaluating new technologies.

editions

Mining IQ Exploration Insights 2025

Gain exclusive insights into the world of exploration in a comprehensive review of the top trending technologies, intercepts, discoveries and more.

editions

Future Fleets Insights 2025

Mining IQ Future Fleets Insights 2025 looks at how companies are using alternative energy sources to cut greenhouse gas emmissions