INTERNATIONAL COAL NEWS

Adani has to pay its own costs in Carmichael court case

INDIAN coal giant Adani may have won a court case against environmentalists in the Queensland Lan...

Lou Caruana

This article is 9 years old. Images might not display.

Adani had sought costs from the Coast and Country lobby group but the Land Court refused the application for costs on Wednesday, with president Carmel MacDonald finding it was not in the court's jurisdiction to award costs in such administrative inquiries.

Coast and Country's legal representative, Environment Defenders Office Queensland principal Sean Ryan, said he welcomed the Land Court's decision not to award costs.

“Community objections to mining are a normal part of the administrative assessment process; important to both the public interest and the protection of the environment,” Ryan said.

But Queensland Resources Council CEO Michael Roche said the decision by the Queensland Land Court to rule that awarding costs was outside of its jurisdiction, “reveals yet another deficiency in the many that infest the Court’s processes”

“The Queensland Resources Council has been appealing to the state government to urgently overhaul the flawed system and today’s judgement in the Adani case, adds yet another piece of evidence to back that argument,” he said.

“We want the Land Court to act like the administrative tribunal it is meant to be, enabling those in the community who are directly affected by a project to have their day in court to object, and then advise the minister of its recommendations.

“Instead, the current Land Court process lacks checks and balances, is too costly, too technical and too lengthy. As the Minister for Natural Resources and Mines Dr Anthony Lynham recently said, 'everyone deserves their day in court, but not four years in court.”

TOPICS:

Expert-led Insights reports built on robust data, rigorous analysis and expert commentary covering mining Exploration, Future Fleets, Automation and Digitalisation, and ESG.

Expert-led Insights reports built on robust data, rigorous analysis and expert commentary covering mining Exploration, Future Fleets, Automation and Digitalisation, and ESG.

editions

ESG Index 2025: Benchmarking the Future of Sustainable Mining

The ESG Index provides an in-depth evaluation of the ESG performance of 60+ of the world’s largest mining companies. It assesses companies across 10 weighted indicators within 6 essential ESG pillars.

editions

Automation and Digitalisation Insights 2025

Discover how mining companies and investors are adopting, deploying and evaluating new technologies.

editions

Mining IQ Exploration Insights 2025

Gain exclusive insights into the world of exploration in a comprehensive review of the top trending technologies, intercepts, discoveries and more.

editions

Future Fleets Insights 2025

Mining IQ Future Fleets Insights 2025 looks at how companies are using alternative energy sources to cut greenhouse gas emmissions