INTERNATIONAL COAL NEWS

Hogsback and the "A" word

Otherwise sane and sensible people have been gripped by this terrible malady.

Lou Caruana

This article is 8 years old. Images might not display.

Otherwise sane and sensible people have been gripped by this terrible malady – rendering them incoherent when they try to talk about the proposed Carmichael coal mine.

What comes out of their mouths at the mere mention of the “A” or “C” word is a profusion of expletives, climate change truths and half-truths and promises to “save the reef for their grandchildren”.

Most recently, the Black Throated Finch has these phobia sufferers all in a flutter. 

Many had never even heard of this obscure bird until the nice people at the Black Throated Finch recovery team and Birdlife Australia claimed the proposed mine would send it extinct.

The Australian Conservation Foundation got wind of the plight of the endangered finch and weighed into the debate, asking the Minister for Energy and Environment Josh Frydenberg to revoke the licences that Adani had duly obtained to get the $16.5 billion Carmichael project off the ground.

This practice of revoking licences is commonplace in New South Wales, and as regular readers of Hogsback might recall, is a recipe for disaster. It’s a sure sign that the neurosis of the masses is starting to spread into government, which already has enough afflictions.

Another tell-tale sign of Adaniphobia is the complete reversal of statements, even if it means supporting something that was hitherto demonised.

A good case in point of this symptom was displayed by the former coal-hating think tank The Australia Institute.

This Canberra-based lobby group used to deny coal had any economic benefit to Australia and exhorted the thousands of people employed in the NSW’s coal mining industry in the Hunter Valley to go out and get other jobs because coal was a dying industry. 

However, The Australia Institute is now rushing to the defence of the poor Hunter Valley coal mining industry, citing research that shows that if Carmichael got up it would lower the price of thermal and cut the lunch of Hunter Valley coal producers.     

The Australia Institute is supporting an increase of Hunter coal export volumes to 235 million tonnes by 2035 from new Hunter mines and the expansion of existing operations. 

NSW Minerals Council CEO Stephen Galilee said it had been very confusing over the years to know where The Australia Institute stood on mining in the Hunter.

“In the past they’ve called for no new mines in the Hunter, arguing this would have little economic impact. They’ve repeatedly lodged submissions and given evidence to the Planning Assessment Commission against almost every new Hunter coal mining application,” he said.

Galilee said the NSW Minerals Council was looking forward to The Australia Institute lodging submissions and giving evidence to the Planning Assessment Commission in support of Hunter coal projects in the future.

Hogsback thinks if that were to miraculously take place, the scourge of Adaniphobia would not be such a bad thing after all.

Expert-led Insights reports built on robust data, rigorous analysis and expert commentary covering mining Exploration, Future Fleets, Automation and Digitalisation, and ESG.

Expert-led Insights reports built on robust data, rigorous analysis and expert commentary covering mining Exploration, Future Fleets, Automation and Digitalisation, and ESG.

editions

ESG Index 2025: Benchmarking the Future of Sustainable Mining

The ESG Index provides an in-depth evaluation of the ESG performance of 60+ of the world’s largest mining companies. It assesses companies across 10 weighted indicators within 6 essential ESG pillars.

editions

Automation and Digitalisation Insights 2025

Discover how mining companies and investors are adopting, deploying and evaluating new technologies.

editions

Mining IQ Exploration Insights 2025

Gain exclusive insights into the world of exploration in a comprehensive review of the top trending technologies, intercepts, discoveries and more.

editions

Future Fleets Insights 2025

Mining IQ Future Fleets Insights 2025 looks at how companies are using alternative energy sources to cut greenhouse gas emmissions