INTERNATIONAL COAL NEWS

Murray Energy to sue US EPA over Clean Water Act

MURRAY Energy Corporation is filing two lawsuits against the US Environmental Protection Agency a...

Lou Caruana

This article is 10 years old. Images might not display.

The first lawsuit has been filed in the US District Court for the Northern District of West Virginia, and the second will be filed in the US Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit.

On the face of it, the Waters of the US rule is a largely technical document that defines which rivers, streams, lakes and marshes fall under the jurisdiction of the EPA and the Army Corps of Engineers.

But opponents like Murray Energy have labelled it yet another power grab. The lawsuits are another step in Murray Energy's legal campaign to stop the EPA’s “illegal actions and to restore the rule of law in this country”, Murray Energy assistant general counsel Gary Broadbent said.

“The Obama EPA's final ‘waters of the US' rule not only reflects an unprecedented expansion in federal regulatory authority, but results in one of the largest land grabs by the federal government in this nation's history,” he said.

“The Obama EPA is seeking to expand jurisdiction over dry ditches, puddles, ponds, and erosional features, dictating to Americans how they can and cannot use their private property.

“Under the Obama EPA's rule, any area that is wet, or has the potential to be wet, would be subject to the Clean Water Act. Congress clearly did not intend such a radical and illogical outcome.”

In 1972, when Congress adopted the Clean Water Act, it expressly limited the federal government's authority to “navigable waters”. Over the years, however, the EPA has engaged in “regulatory creep”, expanding its rules and authority under the Clean Water Act to include not only navigable waters, but dry lands and activities potentially affecting those areas, according to Murray Energy.

In 2001 and 2006, the US Supreme Court rendered opinions that struck down the EPA's impermissible expansion of authority.

The EPA now continues to aggressively push beyond the limits of its authority, according to Broadbent.

TOPICS:

Expert-led Insights reports built on robust data, rigorous analysis and expert commentary covering mining Exploration, Future Fleets, Automation and Digitalisation, and ESG.

Expert-led Insights reports built on robust data, rigorous analysis and expert commentary covering mining Exploration, Future Fleets, Automation and Digitalisation, and ESG.

editions

ESG Index 2025: Benchmarking the Future of Sustainable Mining

The ESG Index provides an in-depth evaluation of the ESG performance of 60+ of the world’s largest mining companies. It assesses companies across 10 weighted indicators within 6 essential ESG pillars.

editions

Automation and Digitalisation Insights 2025

Discover how mining companies and investors are adopting, deploying and evaluating new technologies.

editions

Mining IQ Exploration Insights 2025

Gain exclusive insights into the world of exploration in a comprehensive review of the top trending technologies, intercepts, discoveries and more.

editions

Future Fleets Insights 2025

Mining IQ Future Fleets Insights 2025 looks at how companies are using alternative energy sources to cut greenhouse gas emmissions